Compare

Mudjacking vs Polyjacking vs Replacing the Slab

Three ways to deal with concrete that has dropped, compared on published price, on how long each holds, and on the one question that decides which you should be paying for.

A slab that has sunk is one of the commonest calls we get in the spring, usually a section of driveway by the garage, a walk panel next to the house, or the patio slab under a downspout. The owner has heard of mudjacking, has heard of foam, and wants to know whether either will do or whether the whole thing has to come out.

We should be clear about our interest before going further. The crew we work with breaks out and repours slabs. Raising them is not part of its work, and we have no lifting company to pass you to. That makes this an odd page for us to write, and it is also why we can write it straight: if lifting is the right answer for your slab, the honest thing is to tell you so.

What each method actually does

Mudjacking, sometimes called slabjacking, means drilling holes through the sunken slab and pumping a cement-based slurry underneath under pressure. The slurry fills the void and pushes the panel back up. The holes are on the large side, commonly 1.5 to 2 inches in diameter, and get patched once the lift is done.

Polyjacking does the same job with an expanding polyurethane foam injected through much smaller holes, around half an inch to five-eighths. The foam weighs very little, cures in minutes and does not erode if water gets underneath.

Replacement breaks the panel out, finds out why the ground gave way, corrects the base and places a fresh slab. Of the three, only replacement deals with the concrete itself rather than what is under it.

How the published prices line up

The mudjacking guide at HomeGuide, checked on 11 November 2026, gives national figures for all three methods on one page, which makes it a fair basis for comparison:

MethodPublished national range, per sq ft
Mudjacking (cement slurry)$4 to $9
Polyjacking (polyurethane foam)$8 to $25
Full slab replacement$6 to $15

Two more numbers from the same source change how those rates read in practice. Lifting contractors commonly charge a minimum of $300 to $700 per visit whatever the size, so a single sunken step or walk panel costs far more per foot than the table suggests. And for a full-size driveway of about 450 square feet, HomeGuide gives a mudjacking total of $1,800 to $4,100. The same guide estimates that mudjacking generally comes in 30 to 50 percent below tearing out and repouring.

Read the overlap carefully. Foam at the upper end of its range costs more per foot than a new slab at the lower end of its range. On a big area of weak ground, that is a real comparison to make rather than an assumption that lifting is always the economy option.

Not sure whether yours lifts or comes out?

A crew can tell in a few minutes on site. If it only needs lifting, that is what you will be told, and the estimate costs you nothing either way.

Ask for an on-site look

The question that decides it

Before price, before method: is the concrete itself sound?

Lifting puts a slab back where it was. It does not mend a slab. So the test is whether, once it is level again, you would be happy with the panel you have. One straight crack across an otherwise solid panel is often fine. A panel broken into three or four pieces, a surface that has scaled and is shedding its top layer, or edges crumbling where a car wheel runs, will all still be there after a perfect lift, just at the right height.

If the answer is yes, the concrete is fine and the ground simply moved, lifting is usually the sensible spend and replacement is the expensive way to solve a problem you do not have. If the answer is no, lifting buys time on a slab that was going to need replacing anyway, and you pay for both eventually.

Mudjacking or foam, if you are lifting

That choice belongs to the lifting contractor, but a few things are worth knowing when you talk to them.

  • Weight on soft ground. Slurry is heavy. Where the ground failed because it was soft or saturated, adding weight to it is not ideal, which is the usual argument for foam.
  • Water. If the void was caused by water running under the slab, a cement slurry can wash out over time where foam will not. Fixing the water, though, matters more than either material.
  • Holes. Foam leaves smaller patches. On a decorative or visible surface that can be a reason in itself.
  • Turnaround. HomeGuide gives a slurry lift about a day to cure against around fifteen minutes for foam. For a driveway you need the next morning, that is relevant.

When replacement is the honest answer

Replacement earns its cost in four situations. The concrete is broken up, not just dropped. The panel has sunk more than once after previous lifts, which says the ground beneath is still going. The settlement is so deep that the slab would have to travel a long way to come back. Or the slab is near the end of its life for other reasons, and lifting would be money spent on something you are going to tear out in a few years anyway.

A replacement also lets the crew see what went wrong underneath. Settled panels beside a house are very often sitting on loose backfill from when the foundation was dug, and over a winter or two that material compacts under its own weight. A downspout discharging at the same corner speeds it up. Dig it out, put down properly compacted stone, send the water elsewhere, and the new slab has a much better chance than the old one. How we weigh repair against tear-out more generally is in our framework for repairing or replacing a concrete driveway.

Why panels drop in this part of Lake County

Most of what we see falls into three causes. Backfill that was never compacted, mostly against foundations and over utility trenches. Water, from downspouts, a gutter that overflows at one corner, or a lawn graded toward the slab rather than away from it. And the freeze-thaw season, which here runs long enough that wet ground under a slab heaves in January and turns soft in March. None of this is about frost depth in the code sense; a driveway or a walk floats on the ground, and nobody founds one below the frost line. Cracking caused by the same movement is covered in why concrete driveways crack.

What to do next

Lay a straight edge across the sunken panel and its neighbours. If the panel is in one or two clean pieces and the surface is sound, call a lifting company first; that is the cheaper and quicker fix. If it is broken, scaled, or has been lifted before, the replacement side of the question is on our concrete repair page, and we are happy to look at it and tell you which camp it falls into.

Sources

  1. HomeGuide, mudjacking cost - mudjacking $4 to $9 per square foot; polyjacking $8 to $25; complete slab replacement $6 to $15; minimum job fees $300 to $700; 450 sq ft driveway $1,800 to $4,100; mudjacking 30% to 50% less than replacement; lasts 5 to 10 years or longer; injection holes 1.5 to 2.0 in. (slurry) and 0.50 to 0.63 in. (foam); curing 24 hours (slurry) and 15 minutes (foam). Fetched 11 November 2026.

Get My Free Estimate

Get your free, on-site estimate.

Tell us about your project and we'll call you back the same day to set up a free measure and price.

Get your free quote

Tell us about your project and we will call you back the same day. No obligation.

What are you looking to do?

Free, no-pressure estimate · Serving Lake County, IL

By submitting, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms, and consent to be contacted by phone, text, or email about your project, including by automated means. Consent isn't a condition of purchase. Msg & data rates may apply.

Call (262) 228-5293 Text us