Compare
What a Concrete Quote Should Itemise
Three quotes, three numbers, and no way to tell whether they are for the same work. The eight lines that should appear, and what a missing one usually means.
Most advice about getting concrete work done stops at "get three quotes", which is good advice that leaves you holding three pieces of paper you cannot compare. Concrete is unusually hard to price-check because the expensive decisions are buried, literally, and a finished driveway looks much the same whether the work beneath it was done properly or not. The document you get beforehand is your only real window into that, so it is worth knowing how to read one.
The eight lines that should be there
1. What comes out, and where it goes. Demolition and disposal of the existing surface, stated separately. It is a real cost with real haulage in it, and "removal of existing" with no further detail hides whether reinforcement, thickness or a second buried layer has been accounted for.
2. The excavation depth. How far down the dig goes, not just that digging happens. This sets up everything below.
3. The base: material, depth, and how it is compacted. The single most important line on the document and the one most often missing. "Compacted in layers" is the phrase to look for, because material placed in one thick lift never reaches the density it needed, whatever depth is written down.
4. Slab thickness. Stated as a number. If parts differ, say a thickened area where something heavy stands, that should appear as its own item rather than as a verbal promise.
5. Reinforcement. What, and at what spacing, and how it will be held at the right height in the slab rather than lying on the base.
6. The mix. Particularly whether it is specified for exterior exposure in a freeze-thaw climate. This is the line that decides whether the surface is still intact in ten winters.
7. Joints. Spacing, and whether they are sawn or tooled. To sanity-check the number you are given: it should land between 24 and 36 slab thicknesses, stop at fifteen feet, and the cut should reach a quarter of the depth.
8. Finish, drainage and reinstatement. The surface texture, where water is being sent, and what happens to the strip of ruined lawn along the edge when the crew leaves.
What a missing line usually means
Rarely deception. Usually one of three things, and it is worth knowing which.
Sometimes it is habit: a contractor who has quoted the same way for twenty years and assumes everybody knows what is included. Ask and you get a clear answer immediately, which is reassuring.
Sometimes it is genuine omission, and the item will surface later as an extra. Removal, disposal and reinstating the lawn are the classic three.
And sometimes the line is missing because the number is low. On a job where nobody can inspect the base afterwards, the base is where a price gets cut, and a quote that avoids committing to a depth has kept its options open.
Asking is free and the reaction tells you as much as the answer does.
How to compare three of them properly
Write the eight items down the left of a page and the three contractors across the top, then fill it in. Two useful things happen. The gaps become visible, and the quotes usually stop being as far apart as they looked, because the cheap one turns out to be a thinner base or a slab without removal in it.
Then ask the two questions that do not appear on any quote. Who is actually doing the work, since the person quoting is not always the person pouring. And what happens if it cracks, in writing, including what is excluded. Every slab cracks somewhere; what varies is whether both parties agreed in advance which kinds are covered.
Two things that are not lines but belong in writing
What happens to your garden. A concrete job is heavy work with heavy machinery, and the strip alongside where the crew walked and the barrows ran will be ruined. Whether reinstating that is included, and to what standard, is worth having on paper. Levelled and seeded is a different promise from tidied up.
Access, and what it is assumed to be. Many quotes silently assume a mixer can get within chute reach. If it cannot, every load is barrowed, which is hours rather than minutes, and it is the classic source of a variation appearing mid-job. A contractor who has walked the route and said so in the quote has removed the commonest surprise in this trade.
The one exclusion worth reading carefully
Deicing salt. Almost every guarantee in this trade excludes damage from chemicals applied to young concrete, and that exclusion is reasonable rather than sharp practice. It also means the rule matters to you financially as well as practically: nothing goes on new concrete during the first winter, and that includes the calcium and magnesium chloride products marketed as the safe alternative, both of which the industry lists among the things never to put on concrete.
A contractor who raises that before you sign is doing you a favour. One who does not may still have it in the small print.
What we put on ours
All eight, itemised, and the stage payments written against work reaching a point rather than against dates. Not because it is a sales position, but because a quote that can be compared is a quote you can trust, and this is a trade where the customer genuinely cannot check the important half afterwards.
For what actually drives a total, read the Gurnee driveway cost breakdown. For whether to pay for extra depth, four inches or six argues it out. To be quoted, start at concrete driveway.