Compare

Concrete vs Asphalt Driveway in Northern Illinois

We pour concrete, so read this knowing our bias. Asphalt is genuinely the better answer for some Lake County driveways, and the honest case for each is more useful to you than a sales pitch.

Updated August 2026 · Gurnee Concrete

Declaring the obvious first: this is a concrete company's page. What follows tries to be the comparison we would give a neighbour rather than a prospect, because the version that pretends asphalt has no advantages is both wrong and easy to spot.

What the published figures say

HomeGuide compares the two directly: asphalt at $5 to $12 per square foot installed against concrete at $6 to $15. On a two-car driveway that is $1,200 to $4,000 for asphalt and $1,600 to $6,400 for concrete.

Their national figures, not ours. Asphalt wins the entry price, clearly and consistently. The interesting question is what happens after year one.

Where asphalt genuinely wins

It costs less to install, as above, and on a long rural drive that difference compounds into real money.

It tolerates ground movement. Asphalt is a flexible pavement. When the subgrade shifts through a freeze-thaw season, asphalt tends to deform and settle rather than fracture. On ground that is known to move, that flexibility is a legitimate engineering advantage, not a consolation prize.

Repairs disappear. A patched asphalt driveway can be made to look uniform again. Patched concrete essentially never matches, because you are placing new material against weathered material and the colour difference is permanent.

It goes down fast and opens sooner. Asphalt is usable in a couple of days rather than the week concrete needs before vehicles.

Salt does not trouble it. The winter maintenance that scales concrete surfaces does very little to asphalt.

Where concrete wins

Service life. Built correctly, concrete lasts substantially longer, which is what the higher initial figure is buying.

No resealing cycle. Asphalt wants sealcoating periodically to stay sound. That is a recurring cost and a recurring Saturday, and it continues for as long as you own the driveway.

Summer. Asphalt softens in sustained heat. Trailer jacks, motorcycle stands and kickstands sink into it. Concrete does not care.

Appearance and options. Broom finish, exposed aggregate, stamped, coloured, bordered. Asphalt is black, and then it is faded black.

Fuel and oil. Petroleum products dissolve asphalt binder. A leaking vehicle stains concrete; it damages asphalt.

The local factor that decides it more often than anything else

Neither material rescues bad ground. In this county the frost cycle works on whatever sits beneath the surface, and the failures we are called to look at are overwhelmingly failures of preparation rather than of material choice.

So the practical decision usually runs: if the budget covers concrete properly built - excavated, stone consolidated in passes, adequate depth, air specified for a salted surface, joints planned before the pour - concrete is the better long-term buy. If the budget covers concrete only by economising on those things, a well-built asphalt driveway will serve you better than a thin slab on unprepared ground, and it is not close.

That is the genuinely useful version of this comparison, and it is why we would rather talk about what is under the driveway than which material is on top. The same instinct runs through our comparison of a poured patio with pavers and a deck, where the grade of the yard settles more cases than the material does.

If you choose concrete, the first winter is the one that counts

Salt is the one area where asphalt has an unambiguous edge, so if you go with concrete this matters more than any other aftercare advice on this page. Use nothing chemical at all during the opening winter. A slab that young is still damp inside and has not matured enough to be frozen in that state, and deicing chemicals aggravate both of those things at once.

Beware the common recommendation to substitute magnesium or calcium chloride as gentler products. Regional ready mix guidance places both on its exclusion list, and comparative Oregon DOT testing found magnesium chloride caused the largest compressive strength loss among the chlorides studied. Grit only.

Numbers for your actual driveway

The figures at the top are national. For what either surface costs on your lot, and what the apron adds in Gurnee, see concrete driveway cost in Gurnee. If you are removing an existing surface, what it costs to replace a concrete driveway covers the demolition side. Ready to price it properly, our concrete driveway estimates are free and done on site.